Comparisons
Comparisons: which option suits you best
A QR code isn't the only way to share an address or data, and not always the best one. Sometimes a short link you can read out loud is more convenient, and sometimes you need a code whose content you can change later. It also matters where the code will live: on paper or on a screen. In the tables below we compare the options in general terms, without naming programs or services, so you can choose what fits your task.
It works best when a code and a short link go together: one for the camera, the other for the eye.
How to read the tables: the rows show what usually matters when choosing, the columns show the options themselves. Exact features depend on what you use to make and read the code, so check the result on your own phone.
QR code vs barcode vs short link
| Criterion | QR code | Barcode | Short link |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it holds | An address, text, a contact, network connection details | Usually a short product or document number | Only a website address |
| How it's read | With a phone camera from any side, even at an angle | With a scanner or camera along the bars | By eye: a person types the address |
| Is the content visible | No, not until you scan it | The digits are often printed under the bars | Yes, the address is visible at once |
| Weak spot | Easy to swap with a sticker | Little room for data | A long address is tedious to type |
Static code vs dynamic code (via a redirect)
| Criterion | Static code | Dynamic code |
|---|---|---|
| Where the content is stored | Right in the pattern of the square | The square holds an intermediate address; the final one is kept by whoever runs the redirect |
| Can it be changed | No, only by printing a new code | Yes, the final address can be changed without reprinting |
| What it depends on | Nothing but the code itself | Whether the redirect keeps working |
| What people see | The final address straight away | First an intermediate address that says little |
Printed on paper vs shown on a screen
| Criterion | On paper | On a screen |
|---|---|---|
| Main obstacle | Creased paper, fading, small size | Glare, low brightness, cracked glass |
| Contrast | Depends on the paper and ink | Depends on brightness and viewing angle |
| Swapping | Can be covered with a sticker | Can be swapped if a stranger gets access to the screen or file |
| Updating | Needs a new print run | Just replace the image |
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step guides: codes for your home network, a business card, a menu or a notice, and checking the content before printing. Plus the article catalogue.
- Tools
What comes in handy: your phone camera, the address preview, a text editor, a printer with heavy paper, a ruler and a short link next to the code.
- Problems
The camera can't see the code, the link won't open, the printed code won't scan, the screen glares, or the code leads somewhere wrong or stopped working.
- Glossary
Key terms in plain words: module, finder pattern, quiet zone, error correction, static and dynamic codes, phishing.
- Questions
Answers about this guide, about scanning and making codes, and about using them without putting your data or money at risk.
Sources
- Reference materials on the ISO/IEC 18004 standard
- Editorial materials of this guide
This guide describes working with QR codes in general terms and is accurate as of the preparation date shown on each page. Phone cameras and code-making programs get updated, and their menus look different from device to device. If the prompts on your screen don't match our description, follow the purpose of each step and check your phone's own help pages.